Salt & Pepper Italian Bistro Pizza

We arrived at 8:30 - they close at 9:30. The hostess had to check if dine in was still available. Attempted to order a slice of pizza… at a pizza shop…. And was told they were all out. The staff was flipping chairs and mopping all around us. There was also another table and people still coming in for take out, but we still felt like an inconvenience. We used to live in the area and came here often, however I guess service has changed. Disappointing.

The white pizza was fabulous as was the veggie pizza. Fresh ingredients, great crust and a garlic lovers dream come true!! Awesome service and attentive waitress by Lilah!

So sorry to give a bad review. The food was tasteless. The eggplant was heavy. Everything was fried. The bread was soggy. The sauce on the ravioli was red. That’s the only Italian thing on my dish. No taste. I will not go back. I wanted to go into the kitchen and add spice and taste to their pots!

$20–30

Ordered food from Salt u0026 Pepper for our Christmas luncheon at work. Everything we had--salads, subs, stromboli, and various Italian dinners--was absolutely delicious! Tony allowed us to preorder a few days in advance and even make one change after the fact. The order was on time and and completely accurate, even with a few special requests. I highly recommend Salt u0026 Pepper

$10–20

$10–20

Really enjoyed the gizmo (cheeseburger sub with ham). They use homemade rolls which are good, but they're fairly soft, so don't expect a hard roll. I ordered a large since a large is a pretty average size at most places. This thing was massive. Easily enough for 2 people. The fries were good as well, and just the right amount of crispy without being overdone.

Lots of lunch specials to choose from all under $10. My favorite is the fried fish sandwich with French fries.

While on a recent trip to Lancaster, we decided we wanted Italian food for a change and stumbled happily upon this place. The place was clean, food was delicious, the service was great, and prices were reasonable. We would definitely go back.

$30–50

Their pizza is FANTASTIC!! I love coming here on the rare occasion and always being pleased because it’s so good. They have it in the oven for just the right amount of time. This place is good for usually not too big of a crowd. Anywhere from 1-6 I would say is the typical crowd size. The scenery is very fitting to their name and the employees are nice.