Carvel

Carvel is legendary. No better cake in the world. Went on BOGO sundae night and was a smooth experience.

I purchased a large chocolate ice cream cup for $8.20 with tax, which is fine, the price is the price, but the portion was not completely large, more like a medium sized portion, the inner center of the cup was hollow and empty, as I was eating it the sides fell in towards the middle where there was no ice cream, they just went around the inner wall of the cup and circled around tapering to the top to about an inch above the cup, the servers were very nice and friendly, the Only good thing about this store, I do live locally and today was the last time I go to to this location. A few weeks ago I went to another location, on Old Country Rd just west of Rt 135, and it was completely and totally full of ice cream and at least 2 inches above the top of the cup, I rather drive 8 miles instead of 3/4 of a mile, no matter what the price is, to get what I'm paying for and not deal with a cheap store.

be aware , we purchased two large ice cream ,they charged us $22......

The owner and staff at this carvel are amazing! They created a special, custom cake for my sons birthday and it was the best ice cream cake we have ever had. Process for ordering and pickup could not have been easier and owner executed the cake perfectly. Highly recommended!

I cannot recommend this store enough!! The owner is wonderful and created the most incredible cake for my son’s birthday!! It was as delicious as it was beautiful! Everything was super easy and super reasonably priced! The cake was a massive hit with the kids AND adults, and I will be coming back for all my parties! Highly recommend!!

Carvel in Oyster Bay is the only Carvel that my family and I go to. Jimmy the owner is very accommodating and friendly. He has the best ice cream cakes because they are always fresh and made to order. Jimmy is our go- to- guy for any celebration that we have because we know that we will always get the best and freshest cakes!

Rude, unwelcoming employees that seem annoyed when you come in and try to be a customer. These young kids behind the counter have zero customer service skills.

BEST carvel!!!! Customer service is so nice, atmosphere is peaceful and everyone is so attentive. Just to point out, please respect all of the employees. I get that they’re only teenagers, but they’re better than some of the rest. Don’t get mad at some stupid simple mistake, they’re just doing their job.

$10–20